• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Make Bread

Make Bread

A bread blog for home bakers

  • Bread
  • Pizza

Reminder: Don’t Underproof Your Loaves!

29.04.16 By nick Leave a Comment

failed tartine bread

One of the things I want to do on this site is to share with you the (many) mistakes that I make as a home baker. Not all breads are beautiful, not all loaves are perfect. For one reason or another, I often mess up and want to use this space to share with you pitfalls you will likely face when baking in your own kitchen.




A video posted by Nick (@makebreadnet) on Apr 28, 2016 at 5:41am PDT

There are several challenges that we face as home bakers.  Busy schedules, drafty kitchens, quirky ovens, and rowdy levain starters to name a few.  My biggest mental hurdle is time management.  I believe that a lot of home bakers who use sourdough starters deal with this in different ways and I’ve noticed that when I’m haphazard with time management that the end result often fails to meet my expectations.  Of course, I have no one to blame but myself but I still sometimes forget that I should adjust the bread’s schedule to fit in to my schedule.  It’s difficult at times to make things work and I just need to work on my patience too.

[ezcol_1half]Going in[/ezcol_1half] [ezcol_1half_end]tuned out pretty from the top[/ezcol_1half_end]

I was very excited when making this last batch of Tartine’s Country Loaf.  The starter was rising and falling on a predictable schedule and on point, the hydration was right on and the dough nice and strong.  At the end of the first night I was feeling good.  I decided to let the dough bulk ferment in the fridge for about 20 hours because the next day was going to be busy for me.  When I got to it the next day I let it acclimate at room temp for about an hour before dividing and pre-shaping, then finally shaping and letting it do it’s final proof in the bannetons.  Unfortunately for me, 10pm came too quickly and I decided to put the loaves in the oven instead of waiting another hour.  The loaved turned out tasting great but they did not spring.  They were dense and a little too chewy.  I expected a better, more open, crumb and ended up with a tight one instead.  Not all bad.  I also wanted the bread to darken up a bit and didn’t let them cook enough, probably because I was ready for bed!

cold bulk ferment
Hard to see but it’s 35˚ in there! brrrr!

So, lesson learned.  Let the bread fully proof before baking.  Do the poke test.  Work your bread’s schedule around yours.  I guess I should have let the bread do a final proof in the fridge one and put them straight in to the oven the next morning but for this time, consider this lesson in the books.

 

Filed Under: Bread, Bread Tutorials Tagged With: baking, bread, bread fail, bread tutorial, failed tartine, failure, homemade bread, sourdough, tartine country bread, wild yeast

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

My Story

My name is Nick, an amateur bread baker living in Pennsylvania. I have been making bread since my neighbor in grad school showed me that you could make great bread at home and have fun doing it. Since then I've been hooked and am always looking for ways to improve my baking. Find out more about me and let's get baking together!

Recent Breads

  • Classic French Bread Recipe: Pain Ordinaire Careme
  • Cinnamon Morning Buns with Cardamom
  • Review: Emile Henry Baguette Baker
  • Cinnamon Roll Challah Bread aka ChanniyumRoll
  • Greek Feta Pull Apart Bread – Step By Step
  • Hokkaido Milk Bread
  • Bread with Yeasted Water
  • Everyday Sourdough Bread
  • My First Attempt at Einkorn
  • How to revive a dead sourdough starter

Footer

Search The Archives

Archives

From the Blog

  • Classic French Bread Recipe: Pain Ordinaire Careme
  • Cinnamon Morning Buns with Cardamom
  • Review: Emile Henry Baguette Baker
  • Cinnamon Roll Challah Bread aka ChanniyumRoll
  • Greek Feta Pull Apart Bread – Step By Step

Copyright 2015-2021 Makebread.net